This article explores James A. Tweedie’s poem “But What of Us?” delving into its themes of social inequality, the abuse of power by the wealthy, and the yearning for societal change. We will analyze the poem’s structure, imagery, and emotional impact, highlighting Tweedie’s critique of the imbalance between the “haves” and “have-nots.”
The poem opens by juxtaposing the immense wealth of the “richest men on earth” with their inevitable mortality: “They have it all, / The richest men on earth. / No calculator can compute their worth. / Yet doomed to fall.” This stark contrast immediately establishes a sense of irony—despite their material possessions, even the wealthiest are subject to the same fate as everyone else.
Tweedie then emphasizes the absurdity of their accumulated wealth: “Their wealth immense. / With vast, tax-free amounts / Secured in stocks and offshore bank accounts. / It makes no sense.” The poet questions the ethical implications of such vast fortunes while many struggle to survive. This leads to the central question of the poem: “But what of us / Who live from day to day? / Whose words mean less than what those rich folk say.” Here, Tweedie gives voice to the marginalized, those whose voices are often drowned out by the powerful and affluent.
The poet highlights the powerlessness felt by the common people: “Is this what jus- / tice is for us today? / How powerless it is to feel this way.” He evokes a sense of frustration and injustice, questioning the fairness of a system that allows such disparities to exist.
The poem then shifts towards a call to action: “What can we do, / When rich and famous give / Us lectures as to how we are to live? / They are so few, / But herd us like we’re sheep.” Tweedie criticizes the wealthy for dictating the lives of the majority while remaining detached from their struggles. He urges readers to resist this control: “It’s up to me / And you to call their bluff / And stare them down and say, ‘Enough’s Enough!’” This call to action emphasizes the power of collective resistance against oppressive forces.
Tweedie envisions a future where the power dynamic is reversed: “A dream to sell . . . / But sometimes dreams come true, / When ordinary folk like me and you / Will one day tell / Each so-called so-and-so / How they should live and where they all can go.” This concluding vision offers a glimmer of hope for a more equitable society where the voices of the many outweigh the influence of the few.
“But What of Us?” is a powerful commentary on social inequality. Through its evocative imagery and direct language, the poem resonates with those who feel marginalized and disempowered by the current economic and social order. It serves as a reminder of the importance of speaking out against injustice and striving for a more just and equitable world.
In conclusion, Tweedie’s poem is not just a lament but a call for change, urging readers to question the status quo and actively participate in shaping a better future. It is a testament to the power of poetry to give voice to the voiceless and inspire social action.