Commodore Matthew Perry’s arrival in Japan in 1853 is a pivotal moment in both Japanese and American history, marking the end of Japan’s centuries-long isolationist policy and its forced entry into the modern world. While often credited with “opening” Japan, Perry’s expedition was part of a larger global context of expanding Western influence and the specific economic and political interests of the United States. This article explores the historical context of Perry’s mission, its impact on Japan, and its lasting legacy.
Contents
altCommodore Matthew Perry arriving in Japan.
The Context of Perry’s Expedition
Contrary to popular belief, Perry was not the first Westerner to encounter Japan. Portuguese, Spanish, and Dutch traders had established trade relations with Japan in the 16th and 17th centuries. However, European proselytizing and perceived unfair trade practices led to the expulsion of most foreigners and the implementation of sakoku, a strict isolationist policy, in 1639. For over two centuries, Japan’s interactions with the outside world were severely limited, with only the Dutch and Chinese granted restricted trading privileges.
Several factors converged in the mid-19th century to pique American interest in re-establishing contact with Japan. The opening of Chinese ports to trade and the acquisition of California positioned the United States for increased trans-Pacific commerce. The transition from sail to steam-powered ships necessitated coaling stations along these routes, and Japan’s strategic location, along with rumored coal reserves, made it a prime candidate. Furthermore, the burgeoning American whaling industry in the North Pacific required safe harbors and provisions, while reports of mistreatment of shipwrecked American sailors fueled calls for diplomatic intervention.
altTownsend Harris, the first U.S. Consul to Japan.
The Perry Mission and Gunboat Diplomacy
Motivated by economic considerations and a sense of Manifest Destiny, the United States aimed to “modernize” and “civilize” Japan. While some advocated for religious conversion, others saw forced trade as mutually beneficial. Earlier American attempts to engage with Japan had been rebuffed, but in 1851, President Millard Fillmore authorized a formal naval expedition led by Commodore Matthew Perry.
Perry’s strategy involved a calculated display of naval power combined with diplomatic overtures. He initially visited the Ryukyus and Bonin Islands, asserting American claims and demanding cooperation, before proceeding to Edo (Tokyo) Bay. Carrying a letter from President Fillmore addressed to the Emperor (a misunderstanding of the Japanese political structure), Perry’s arrival with a squadron of warships signaled American strength. Simultaneously, he presented gifts showcasing Western technology – a steam locomotive, a telegraph, and more – intended to impress the Japanese with Western superiority.
The Treaty of Kanagawa and its Aftermath
Perry’s forceful approach prompted the Japanese authorities to accept Fillmore’s letter. The following year, he returned with a larger fleet, further pressuring the Japanese to negotiate. In 1854, the Treaty of Kanagawa was signed, granting protection to shipwrecked Americans, opening two ports (Shimoda and Hakodate) for provisioning American ships, and allowing for the appointment of a U.S. consul. While not a full commercial treaty, it included a most-favored-nation clause, paving the way for future trade agreements.
Townsend Harris, the first U.S. consul to Japan, arrived in Shimoda in 1856. Facing greater resistance without Perry’s naval backing, he eventually secured the Harris Treaty in 1858, establishing formal commercial relations between the two nations. European powers soon followed suit, concluding their own treaties with Japan.
The Legacy of Commodore Perry
Commodore Matthew Perry’s expedition initiated a chain of events that irrevocably altered Japan’s trajectory. While the opening of Japan was ultimately achieved through “gunboat diplomacy,” its consequences were profound. Access to Western technology and ideas facilitated Japan’s rapid modernization, particularly in its military, transforming it into a major power in the Pacific. However, the forced nature of this interaction weakened the Tokugawa Shogunate, culminating in the Meiji Restoration of 1868, which restored imperial rule and ushered in an era of profound social and political change. Perry’s mission remains a complex and controversial legacy, symbolizing both the transformative power of globalization and the potential for coercion in international relations.